January 7th, 2005

Rahul Saxena. Who’s that ?

Rahul Saxena

Rahul Saxena wouldn’t have featured here if I wouldn’t have heard him sing. He wouldn’t even be known to a 1000 people throughout his life if only he didn’t participate in Sony’s Indian Idol competition. Today Rahul Saxena is a hero. A true spirited gentleman.


Rahul came into the competition with a great singing talent but had no clue that he could also become an Indian Idol. He didn’t have a great personality of a Pop star. He was just the average joe from the Indian middle class. Obviously because of his singing gift and quaint charm, he rose up to the top 10 singers category in the competition. The short-listed singers were made to stay in a star hotel. Rahul became a friend of all. He had an attitude that made everyone love him and his voice that was as nice as him.

Today, on an elimination round of Indian Idol, there were 8 singers alongwith Rahul Saxena. Based on yesterday’s round of singing, Indians had voted through SMS. Shockingly, Rahul was eliminated today. The audience were dismayed. His fellow participants Aditi and Amit Sana were literally crying. The judges were completely blown-away. Farah Khan couldn’t believe the scene and was in tears. Sonu Nigam seemed to be the most upset off all. For me it was the only show where the judges cried on a participant’s fate.

Rahul stood nearly in tears but chose to sing a bye-bye song. The crowd alongwith the judges gave him a standing ovation and he was still there in the middle, singing as merrily as ever. Entusiasm is infectious. Rahul Saxena proved it yet-another-time.

P.S : Due to heavy comment posting, I’m closing the comments for this post. Thanks.

639 Responses to “Rahul Saxena. Who’s that ?”


  1. If only blogs could sing.

    Posted by: sat | January 8th, 2005 - 8:54 am

  2. Whoa !! I wish too, Sat.

    Posted by: Lazy Geek | January 8th, 2005 - 9:25 am

  3. If only I could sing so well!….:(

    Posted by: Xena | January 8th, 2005 - 10:42 am

  4. Ive seen him sing b4 on Saregamapa …..he sung a soon to be released song composed by Himesh Reshamaiyya……and it was terrrific! Saregamapa on Zee is a not to be missed programme!

    Posted by: Raj | January 8th, 2005 - 7:30 pm

  5. I hate Indion Idol now! They kicked Rahul Saxena out???? Indians are crazy.

    Posted by: Mk | January 9th, 2005 - 9:10 am

  6. Star Cast Puppet Jury + Politics + Emotions + Story Telling + Lots of Crap = Indian Idol.

    Posted by: avaiz | January 9th, 2005 - 6:46 pm

  7. I’ve seen Rahul Saxena on SAREGAMAPA and I was strongly feeling that he will be there giving tough time to all others in Indian Idol as well. Its really bad-luck at his end that Indians failed completely to recognize his shear talent. A singer like Sonu Nigam gave comments like he will be in top three when he performed in first audition. I’m sure that some or the other day Rahul will achieve all success in his life which he deserves. Amit Sana is also having great voice….Please cast your votes based on contestant’s talent and not on emotions henceforth else we might see Ravinder Ravi becoming Indian Idol and you may get his album to listen on Sony Music. If he becomes Indian Idol I’m sure all jury members will commit suicide and his album will be the greatest hit after Altaf Raja’s Tum to thehere pardesi!!!!!!

    Posted by: Rahul Kharat | January 10th, 2005 - 12:29 pm

  8. Guys and Gals from Rahul’s college why dont you call a protest march against this wrong decision??? I’m sure energy levels of Mumbai guys are always high in such matters. You do that in planned way by informing all media centers that we are going to have a protest march in Mumbai so that will be covered. Belive me you will get lot of support from other colleges as well.

    Posted by: Rahul Kharat | January 10th, 2005 - 1:31 pm

  9. With him gone, who do you think is the favourite or deserving candidate now? I like Amit Sana’s singing.

    Posted by: Maverick | January 10th, 2005 - 3:07 pm

  10. Yes I Agree….If not Rahul Saxena then Amit Sana is my next choice….

    Posted by: Rahul Kharat | January 10th, 2005 - 4:48 pm

  11. Bad luck for Indian Idol
    This is totaly wrong. we are just shocked. This is wrong decesion. In
    this case what is the inportance of judjes here? we are here to choose
    a good talent and a good voice not for choosing a good or bad background.
    If such type of decision are taken by our public then i think that we are
    not choosing our indian idol rather we are choosing a minister as in the
    election. What is the importance of 18 lack votes they are of no use. There
    is no need of judjes here. Judjes has to play there roles just like a
    statue. after getting today’s result we saw that they are helpless. They
    have no power in there hands and i think that they are also not satisfied
    with this result. and i also think that through such type of decesion
    we never choose our indian idol who has good voice and talent.
    In Indian Idol we saw that Rahul Saxena was one of the best
    contestent among all of them. But in today’s result episode we saw that
    he has voted out and if such types of decesions are taken in next 2 or
    3 weeks contineuosly then there will be no more good talent will be left
    in indian idol. But we can also solve such type problems. The remedy is
    we should give only 50% power to choose the best contestent to public
    and rest 50% power to judjes or we can also give one more chance to the
    good contestents as the judjes given in the piano round.
    Rahul Saxena you are the BEST Your’s fithfuly
    Dheerj Narayan

    Posted by: Dheeraj Narayan | January 10th, 2005 - 11:51 pm

  12. http://www.petitiononline.com/saxena9/petition.html

    support to it guys..
    try ur best to get rahul back..
    people are trying thier best..
    try getting some gud and influential people for the same..i hope u all will try….and give it best!1

    Posted by: anonymous | January 11th, 2005 - 2:13 am

  13. WE JUST WANT RAHUL SAXENA BACK.HE DESERVE TO BE THE INDIAN IDOL.

    Posted by: FROM BANGLADESH | January 11th, 2005 - 10:56 am

  14. this is so unfair… he was one of the most deserving guys…

    Posted by: padma | January 11th, 2005 - 4:43 pm

  15. Need to have a change in the Indian Idol short-listing method. I feel present method do not give any authority to jury members. From last three weeks it’s clearly observed that Indian people couldn’t understand the comments by judges for each candidate. Result of it…we lost a valuable talent like Rahul. I think jury members should select the last three candidates based on their performances and aggregate markings given by each member (If required they can call one or two more members, professional singers to be a part of judges panel instead calling a celebrity) and Indians should be asked only to give votes to last three members chosen by the judges panel. The person having least votes out of three will go out of competition. This will definitely do the justice….
    Unfortunately this will not be in favor of the sponsors of the program because the number of sms will definitely reduce.

    Posted by: Rahul Kharat | January 11th, 2005 - 6:01 pm

  16. I was heartbroken! Indian Idol holds no more interest for me. There has to be a way to bring him back?!?!?!?

    Posted by: Vidya | January 11th, 2005 - 10:07 pm

  17. It is totally unfair
    Bring him back… he deserved to be the winner

    Posted by: Anushka | January 12th, 2005 - 3:25 pm

  18. Indians are out of there senses they have no idea what they are doing. The people who don’t have any knowledge of music they are EMOTIONAL FOOLS and they are blindly voting for a person who doesn’t even know how to sing sa re ga ma the basic musical notes. INDIAN IDOL should have a theme on classical based then RAVINDER RAVI is automatically out of the show then we don’t have to do anything much to take him out of INDIAN IDOL. So Indians, before casting ur votes think twice who has the real talent in him/her and not to see who has the worst background and then cast your vote. If the voting system continuous like this no wonder one day we will have RAVINDER RAVI as INDIAN IDOL CHOSEN BY THE INDIANS. No wonder cos of such emotional fools we have leaders like laloo and others who are just the cartoon in the newspapers. To keep the trp’s of the show we need audience involvement but not this extent come on judges also should be given a chance cos they were the one who sloughed thr so many lakhs of candidates to select these final 11. When the last 3 contestants with least votes are chosen the judges should come and take the power back and tell who should actually be voted out. I think this way there will some justice done to the remaining talented contestants like Amit sana, Prajakta and others.

    SONY should take some steps to change the voting system if not completely atleast a part of the system can be changed.

    COME ON sony WAKE UP BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE TO REPENT FOR UR VOTING SYSTEM.

    Posted by: Mohana | January 12th, 2005 - 5:40 pm

  19. This resulting episode of the 3rd gala round would be the most unforgettable episode of INDIAN IDOL, we lost such a true talent just cos of some huge group of emotional fools out there siting and voting who cannot understand what is MUSIC.

    Indians are out of there senses they have no idea what they are doing. The people who don’t have any knowledge of music they are EMOTIONAL FOOLS and they are blindly voting for a person who doesn’t even know how to sing sa re ga ma the basic musical notes. INDIAN IDOL should have a theme on classical based then RAVINDER RAVI is automatically out of the show then we don’t have to do anything much to take him out of INDIAN IDOL. So Indians, before casting ur votes think twice who has the real talent in him/her and not to see who has the worst background and then cast your vote. If the voting system continuous like this no wonder one day we will have RAVINDER RAVI as INDIAN IDOL CHOSEN BY THE INDIANS. No wonder cos of such emotional fools we have leaders like laloo and others who are just the cartoon in the newspapers. To keep the trp’s of the show we need audience involvement but not this extent come on judges also should be given a chance cos they were the one who sloughed thr so many lakhs of candidates to select these final 11. When the last 3 contestants with least votes are chosen the judges should come and take the power back and tell who should actually be voted out. I think this way there will some justice done to the remaining talented contestants like Amit sana, Prajakta and others.

    SONY should take some steps to change the voting system if not completely atleast a part of the system should be changed atleast now before it is too late.

    COME ON sony WAKE UP BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE TO REPENT FOR UR VOTING SYSTEM.

    Posted by: Mohana | January 12th, 2005 - 5:46 pm

  20. Please sign the petition at the url mentioned below and try our best to bring Rahul Saxena back to the show. He deserves to be given another chance.

    Posted by: Pallavi | January 13th, 2005 - 9:54 pm

  21. i really felt sorry 4 rahul.. He was brilliat everywre..but still he cudnt make it.. unfortunate.. I don have much cognizance of music and i dont understand abt the SUR and TAL tht sonu talks often..

    But felt Rahul vaidya and Rahul Saxena wre veryveryvery gud…and Rabindra Ravi..is ordinary.. Actually i too felt pitty on Ravi whn i saw him cryin with the applause of anu malik …
    but now i feel more pitty 4 others… I am thoroughly sure tht Rahul saxena deserved more thn Ravi

    But then most of us thot like tht no??
    Wat aditi paul said is very true.. Sangeet SaraswathiDevi hai.. sangeeth ki apamaan saraswathi devi ki apaman hai..

    Let us say together.. we r not goin to vote with an emotional mind.. v need to give thm who deserve…

    and i get a feelin th Rabindra ravi got more thn wat he deserved by now….

    Now lets give othes who thoroughly deserve more than any others…

    So plz keep ur heart aside..use ur brain and vote..

    Posted by: enchanter | January 14th, 2005 - 3:09 pm

  22. rahul was gr8……..get him back

    Posted by: aishwarya | January 15th, 2005 - 3:36 pm

  23. I strongly feel that Rahul Saxena is a victim of politics of regionalism.Evaluation & shortlisting of candidates is fundamentally defective as it is based on the following assumptions :

    aa. All the SMSing indians have perfect sense for evaluating the good music.

    bb. Voting is thoroughly unbiased irrespective of region,caste,creed or gender.

    cc. The ultimate INDIAN IDOL would be creme de la creme.

    I am afraid, all the above assumptions have now proved to be irrational & totally wrong. It seems, the producers are not serious about the business. The methodology for shortlisting is totally un-professional & this will do more harm to indian music. In fact, whole tamasha of eliminating process has made a mockery of good music.

    Posted by: s narayanan | January 15th, 2005 - 4:16 pm

  24. i havnet felt sooo bad for any other person on tv.. i mean …. rahul saxena … was just tooooooooo good …! i still remember …he sang tanhayi … n i was … sooo … sooo .. blah! .. cant get words to explain …
    he was surely one person who desreved to be the indian idol … i dont think ravinder deserves all this sympathy … he hasnt been doin any good in any of the gala rounds.. but ofcourse the piana round .. he did gr8! .. but .. but … how can rahul saxena be voted out … hes 10000 times better than ravinder…
    the day of he got out … i happened to be watching this … i couldnt believe it… i cried … cried like …. ah!…n then i answered tonsa calls… everybody was soooo damn depressed… i guess … judgin shouldnt be left completely to the janta… the judges have to have their say … rahul saxena wd have neva gone out .. if sensible ppl were judgin…
    i seriusoly feeel sooo bad when i think of indian idol without rahul saxena ..! ..
    cmon … do something .. sony … get him back …!

    Posted by: darshana | January 15th, 2005 - 4:28 pm

  25. The elimination of Rahul Saxena has proved that ultimately the mediocracy only will prevail over the good sense in this country.

    Producers, please note that selecting the best talent is not politics, apart from shattering individual’s aspirations & career, its most damaging effect is the qualily of music that that would be imposed on us in future.

    Posted by: sarika | January 15th, 2005 - 4:36 pm

  26. The elimination of Rahul Saxena followed by Harish Mayal does not make any sense.

    The programme has now lost all its charm & respect, get Rahul Saxena back to restore the good old enthusiasm & attraction of this programme.

    Posted by: anjum jamal | January 15th, 2005 - 4:47 pm

  27. dear rahul, never mind this happens only in india.i remember u had already made it thro’ sa-re-ga-ma mega final. people who voted u out will soon realize their mistake, when they will suffer the same setback & taste the same in their personal lives.

    Posted by: kirit h patel | January 15th, 2005 - 4:57 pm

  28. Bring Back Rahul Saxena. The true Indian Idol. Please Bring Him Back

    Posted by: vijay | January 15th, 2005 - 5:43 pm

  29. I glad that I got out from competetion i never wabted to become an idol bye

    Posted by: rahul saxena | January 15th, 2005 - 6:35 pm

  30. The voting system can’t be changed because it is not in the hands of Sony. Indian Idol is a sister show of the show, American Idol and is the product of the same guy who started the American version. He has also started British, Australian and South African versions. And now he has tapped into the Indian industry too. This is his show and these are his rules.
    However, Sony should think of a way to bring Rahul back because that is something they can definitely do. If they could bend rules when Priyanka dropped out and Amit Tandon was given another chance, or when Aditi performed in one round less when she was down with chicken pox, I think Rahul should be brought back on “public” demand. Since the “public” is the king here, we should be able to convince Sony to bring him back. I don’t know if the petition will work but hopefully if someone with a heart and brain working on the Sony team comes across it and decides to do something, then we may be in luck. It’s nice to see so many more people from the same Indian public who realise Rahul’s talent because I was beginning to lose faith.
    It doesn’t matter what the outcome of the show is because Rahul Saxena is MY INDIAN IDOL!

    Posted by: Vidya | January 15th, 2005 - 10:04 pm

  31. It is true that those sitting as judges are itself not true to their music. Annu malik copies all his songs from everybody in the world. Sonu Nigam became star just copying others, he did not have his own voice. Poor Farah does not know what is singing, she know only Mujrah. How can she and the remaining two do justice to this show. Sony pls in future do not bring who voilates copy wright by themselves.

    Posted by: Yousef | January 16th, 2005 - 7:44 pm

  32. Stop voting system or bring RAHUL SAXENA back to INDIAN IDOL

    Posted by: shamna | January 16th, 2005 - 11:26 pm

  33. What happened with Rahul Saxena was really injustice.This shouldn’t have happened to such a talented person.He should be brought back.This VOTING system should be thrown out.Are these people Stupid????????????? What are the JURY for?
    BRING RAHUL BACK

    Posted by: sabnam | January 17th, 2005 - 12:41 am

  34. Bring rahul saxena back and ravinder ravi out .ravinder ravi looks like monkey and sings like phatta dhol .He has no knowledge of music . and he is not fit to be indion idol. Last week it was not fair when same unjustice was done for harish and prajakta

    Posted by: seema | January 17th, 2005 - 11:19 am

  35. RAHUL VAIDYA IS THE BEST.
    HE’S THE MOST VERSATILE OF ALL
    N
    RAVINDRA RAVI SHOULD DROP OUT HIMSELF ‘COZ HE’S BARRING EVERYONE’S WAY

    Posted by: KOPAL | January 18th, 2005 - 12:47 am

  36. WHEN RAVINDER WAS SINGING TARA RARA IT FELT AS IF WE WERE IN A BAARAT LISTENING TO SOME LOCAL BEND WALA
    HE DESERVES TO BE THERE ONLY
    BUT
    I LIKE AMIT SANA
    HE’S MY BLACK PEARL

    Posted by: TARUN | January 18th, 2005 - 12:51 am

  37. I have heard that Rahul Saxena got an offer from Farah khan to sing in her next film. Is this true?
    I heard that there was an article in HT saying that on 17 jan.

    Posted by: vikas | January 18th, 2005 - 2:04 pm

  38. I like Rahul Saxena

    Posted by: Halim | January 18th, 2005 - 3:11 pm

  39. i think indian idol show has lost its charm.
    Because they have played a bad politics.
    I hope u people understand what i m saying about.
    They just want to make their show in the news and the foolish people like we discuss about this things because we all are imotionally blackmailed by indian idol. Thats all.
    From Beggining Rahul Saxena was my favourite when i show and listen him in Saregama. He has every thing which a indian idol should have but he is a victim of politics. I m guy of Marketing so i know what have been cokked behind this.
    all u people remember the case of mihir in Kyuki?
    the same case is here.

    But honestly speking when rahul saxena was voted out then i cried so much because he , amitsana , rahul vaidya and aditipaul have impressed me so much. these people have done so much sttrugles.they are talented enough but god knows what happend and what will happen.

    Posted by: paras shah | January 19th, 2005 - 1:58 pm

  40. today we are talking about rahul’s case but u people know the cheating has already started from begining. When indian idol judges came to my city the most famous and top singers of the city were not given any chance to give audition.
    The person like raviraj can make to enter into last gala rounds but a singer learning music from last 12 years can entet even audition room?
    How rubbish. This show is nothing.
    I request indian idol team to packup their programme and not to start any others idiot show like this.

    They have proved their slogan : “sabkuch Bhula de”
    now we are saying ” Hum Indian Idol Ko Bhula De’.

    Posted by: paras shah | January 19th, 2005 - 2:15 pm

  41. what will happen if raviraj will become Indian Idol?

    Posted by: paras shah | January 19th, 2005 - 2:39 pm

  42. what will happen if raviraj will become Indian Idol?

    there is a chance for him because if laloo can become railway minister then he why can not become indian idol.

    Posted by: paras shah | January 19th, 2005 - 2:40 pm

  43. Rahul Vaidya is a real Indion Idol.
    Best of luck for Rahul.
    From Sonia

    Posted by: Sonia | January 19th, 2005 - 3:49 pm

  44. hi ilove rahul sexana
    he is very good singer.
    please send email add and add of rahul.
    its very thank
    he is a good singer of india
    thank to faraha khan to give him a chance.

    Posted by: bijaya | January 19th, 2005 - 6:21 pm

  45. hi i am from nepal
    i love rahul sexana
    he is good singer
    please send rahul email add and add in this email
    pls i am his great fan of him

    Posted by: suhana | January 19th, 2005 - 6:41 pm

  46. HAI RAHUL,
    RAHUL i want to know what makes u to sing this way,u have been blessed by god with this art u have that pain in ur voice u made me cry RAHUL.We miss u RAHUL u r the real indian idol but yes very soon we will buy FARAH KHAN,s new film,s music to listen to you.

    Posted by: Navita singh | January 21st, 2005 - 10:07 am

  47. hi rahul….i really love u…..n i really miss u…u r a veryyy deserving person 2 b thwe indian idol but not 2 worry now i’ll hear u next in farah’s next movie which is HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!….take care
    mansi.

    Posted by: mansi | January 21st, 2005 - 8:12 pm

  48. I was shocked by the result of the indian idol where rahul Saxena got out… hay Indians r u made?????? why u all thinking from the hearth u sould realize the importance of indian idol .. this will not just giving too muchhh money to the idol but also it will bring him/her to the star, that’s Rahul deserved it.. plz wake up and protest against the decision…. and bring him back to the show……… rahul Saxena is a real hero, and i know every one wants to see him in the show.. so bring a protest call to the Sony, and mail them to bring Rahul Saxena in the show

    Posted by: Junaid Alam | January 21st, 2005 - 9:33 pm

  49. Hey
    Rhul Saxena, the most deserving person got out of the contest. I felt really bad. He should be brought back. We love you Rahul.

    Posted by: eesha | January 23rd, 2005 - 3:19 pm

  50. dear rahul,
    i felt like crying when u were out. That show is third class. U r our indian idol forever.

    Posted by: iravati | January 23rd, 2005 - 3:27 pm

  51. HI I AM AMAR I HAVE SEEN ALL THE EPISODES OF INDIAN IDOL AND NEVER MISSED ONE I DONT FEEL LKE WATCHING T.V. WITHOUT INDIAN IDOL…. I KNOW RAHUL SAXENA WAS GUD BUT AS I SAID THAT ALL THE 11 HAVE BEEN BROUGHT TO THAT STAGE BY THE JUDGES…..SO NOW THE PUBLIC KNOWS WHO IS WHAT COZ ITS THERE CHANNEL SO CHILL AND WATCH THE FUN……

    Posted by: Amarinder singh marwah | January 23rd, 2005 - 11:52 pm

  52. attention fans of rahul saxena.. hope u’ve heard the album released by sony, with PAL n other songs. hes sung beautifully n ppl will surely pay him attention he so deserves. i dont think we need to worry bout singers like Rahul Saxena. as they say veerane mein bhi phol khilte hain…. he is so talented that he will surely find a place for himself in the industry.

    Posted by: padma | January 24th, 2005 - 3:29 pm

  53. Dear Rahul,
    really you are an idol even though you didnt made it in Indian Idol contest. Really we miss you in the competition as you were singing like a real star…
    Have a great future

    Posted by: lakshmi | January 24th, 2005 - 3:42 pm

  54. hey that waz really bad of them 2 thro out rahul saxena.poor guy!!i wish we cud vote out d judges 2222

    Posted by: me | January 24th, 2005 - 5:53 pm

  55. Hi,
    Rahul.
    I m one of the great fan of u.
    U r the real Indian idol.
    We love u.
    We miss u in the Indian Idol.
    I had seen u in the sa re ga ma pa on zee tv at that time only I fall in love with u.byeee,,,

    Posted by: prachi | January 24th, 2005 - 6:58 pm

  56. rahul you sing fantasticly never mind u lost this chance oppurtunities will come to ur way
    may be a bigger wealth is waiting for u
    have faith on god and he will reward u.
    hope this message will reach u

    Posted by: shagun | January 25th, 2005 - 8:28 am

  57. I’m sure that Ravinder Ravi has promised his fellow Punjabi citizens that he would paint all their homes if he bcums the Indian Idol therefore they are each giving him a 100 votes to get him over.For him all the other participants have to suffer. Rahul Saxena was voted out, Prajakta came twice in the bottom 3. I also b’liv that Aditi Paul should be voted out. She’s too unsmart for the post of Indian Idol. My favourites are- Amit Sana, Prajakta and Rahul Vaidya. They r highly cute and any 1 of them wud do well as the Indian Idol.

    Posted by: Chandreyee | January 25th, 2005 - 5:05 pm

  58. hi!
    Rahul Saxena was really good! he doesn’t need a politicised show like indian idol to get his talent recognized. indian idol is not worth him!!

    Posted by: Shruti | January 25th, 2005 - 9:02 pm

  59. Hai boss

    You were just great at the Indian Idol.Never mind that you were eliminated. Failures are common and one has to fight his way.Your humble attitude reflected your persoanality on screen.A path without any hurdles and challenges leads to nowhere. Almighty is there with you.

    Bye big brother

    Posted by: pramod | January 27th, 2005 - 5:22 pm

  60. RAHUL VAIDYA is the best. But RAHUL SAXENA was also very good. He atleast deserved to be in the final three. AMIT SANA and ADITI PAUL are also good.But I don’t like RAVINDER RAVI, hope today he is out of the show.

    Posted by: alisha | January 28th, 2005 - 6:42 pm

  61. Hi Rahul,
    You are surely the best, if anyone else right now in Indian idol can come close to u, its only Rahul Vaidya…but u r definitely my Indian Idol, i heard the album released by Indian Idol and i must say that u have sung beautifully in your own style, u dint try to copy kishore da which is the best part, i m sure that u will be a successful playback singer one day, u shud never stop trying…
    Nidhi

    Posted by: Nidhi | January 28th, 2005 - 10:38 pm

  62. Hi!
    I want the address of ADITI PAUL and PRAJAKTA SUKRE . Can I get this two ?

    Posted by: Ms. Manami Basu | January 29th, 2005 - 3:04 am

  63. hi
    rahul
    how are you. ihope you are fine there.
    you are a my indian idol.
    sony t.v. told other .but you are my hero
    dont cry you are my grat friend.i say sony tv pls. we just want only rahul saxena.rahul your fello amit sana also good but. i cant agree.this type voting disizen.god blesh you. you sing and like india’s bestboy bye and meet me online pl.my self jagruti barot and i am skin care con. and finacial advisor also ok bye. i like you

    Posted by: jagruti barot | January 29th, 2005 - 1:59 pm

  64. I dont know whats wrong with people and sony entertainment television.How can they eliminate ADITI PAUL AND RAHUL SAXENA and choose Ravinder ravi.Emotions are OK upto a point but this is getting way yoo much.If this continues,then we will end up with an amateur indian idol and lots of regrets,Jaago INDIA Jaago.

    Posted by: vinaymaloo | January 29th, 2005 - 2:04 pm

  65. hi
    i want rahul & aditi email id and mini & aman varma addresh and email id pls. i want just talk
    about his future pls contect me .

    Posted by: jagruti barot | January 29th, 2005 - 2:07 pm

  66. indian idol is a fun show to watch.RAHUL VAIDYA IS MY FAVOURITE.but the chronology of the elimination is going haywire!rahul saxena n vishal kothari shoulnt hav gone .they were tooo good.nyways RAHUL VAIDYA IS THE NEXT INDIAN IDOL!ALL THE BEST TO THE REMAINING CONTESTANTS!

    Posted by: shruti | January 29th, 2005 - 5:15 pm

  67. Indian idol is the most pathetic show i’ve ever seen in my life…Rahul saxena was the best..he got voted off at such an early stage…and now indian ppl voted aditi paul off..wat is the problem with all u ppl..cant u indians use ur mind instead of heart…wake up..now i dont wanna see amit sana going out next, then prajakta and rahul, abhijeet..only to be left with Ravinder ravi..the phatta dhol of this century…to shorten up again..indian idol sucks big time! plus all u foolish ppl who voted off deserving contestants……..

    Posted by: owais | January 30th, 2005 - 8:01 pm

  68. AFTER THE RAHUL SAXENA, THE ONLY DESERVING CANDIDATE FOR THE INDIAN IDOL IS ” AMIT SANA ”
    WHICH IS ACCEPT BY EACH AND EVERYBODY, SONU NIGAM’S CHOICE NO-1 IS ONLY AMIT SANA. SO AMIT WILL BE THE BRIGHTING SINGING STAR OF BOLLYWOOD.

    Posted by: Neha Singh | January 31st, 2005 - 2:11 am

  69. What is more important is that Ravinder Ravi should be thrown out…..We are not here for charity…..if possible, definitely Rahul Saxena and even Aditi Paul should be brought back.

    Posted by: ASIT | January 31st, 2005 - 1:46 pm

  70. I think Ravidra Ravi should withdraw from competition… he is so irritating… aur else Sony guys should get him out of the show no matter how India votes… he doesn’t deserve to be in this kind of shows..

    Posted by: Yogesh | January 31st, 2005 - 5:12 pm

  71. what can i do to join indial idol plz tell me like my idol rahul saxena

    Posted by: umair | January 31st, 2005 - 5:46 pm

  72. Amit sana is the best.He should be indian idol.His talent will tell the future.I am also sorry for rahul saxena.I think voting system has to be changed.It needs to keep major percentage of marks from the judge bcoz they(except farah) do understand music very well.If not i think rabindra will be the indian idol.Finally *indian idol* must be a farce.
    So organizer pls think of it

    Posted by: Bikram | February 1st, 2005 - 2:18 am

  73. Hi,
    I wld like to differ. But I feel Ravinder Ravi would and should go on to become the Indian idol. He is the real face of India, and not the judges who say that people do not know how to vote. How can they say so, when the people who vote are the people who buy Anu malik’s tunes, sonu nigam’s casettes and watched Farah’s Main hoon na.

    I do not care about how Ravi sings, but I hate the way he is treated by tne judges and he should become the IDOL just to show people their place.

    Subu

    Posted by: Subu | February 1st, 2005 - 3:29 pm

  74. AMIT SANA
    TU TO HAI BADA SHANA!
    HAI YEH SAARI DUNIYA NE MANA.
    PAR TU YEH NA JANA,
    TU NE BANA DIYA MUJHE APNA DIWANA.
    LAST ROUND TAK TUJHE ZAROOR HAI AANA.
    WAHAN AAKAR TU ITNA ACCHHA GANA,
    SONU,FARAH,ANU NA DE SAKEN TUJHE KOI TANA.
    PHIR SARE VOTES TU HI PANA.
    AAGE KYA??
    EK KAROD TERA HOGA KHAZANA,
    HAMARA INDIAN IDOL TU HI BAN JANA!!!

    Posted by: shwetha | February 1st, 2005 - 4:35 pm

  75. hi amit
    u r the best. keep going the way u are!!!!u r my indian idol. all the best!!!!

    Posted by: vani | February 1st, 2005 - 10:40 pm

  76. hi
    hey could i get amit sana’s mail ID plzzzzz!!!!!!!all the best to u sana! u r the best!!!

    Posted by: vani | February 1st, 2005 - 10:43 pm

  77. Rahul vaidya is simply superb.He is the ideal Indian Idol.Plzzzzzzzzzzzz send me his details and E-mail Id.

    Posted by: atrayee | February 2nd, 2005 - 1:23 pm

  78. hi rahul/ rahul

    i like the show indian idol but SET has choosn a very pathetic way of choosing them what i mean is infinite voting to the same contestents…..coz of this v have lost RAHUL SAXENA, ” THE PACKAGE OF TALENTS”. But thanks to farah khan for what she has decided is really worthy ……….. anyways one rahul india has already lost but NOT AGAIN think twice before voting… stop being emotional fools…. stop giving sympathy votes for india want a star… and its none other than ‘THE TALENTED RAHUL VAIDYA. U r just superb, cute smile….. beutiful voice. i have wathched u from the piano round and u have given given all the best performences till date, but noone else.
    take care hoping 2 c u as our ‘FIRST INDIAN IDOL’

    PLZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZGIVE ME RAHUL VAIDYA’S AND RAHUL SAXENA E-MAIL ID

    Posted by: asmi | February 2nd, 2005 - 2:01 pm

  79. You are really a nice singer.I AM Suruchi.I like your voice.

    Posted by: Suruchi | February 2nd, 2005 - 2:50 pm

  80. I am a big fan of Rahul Saxena…He remains my Indian Idol no matter what others have to say.. Does anyone have his email id/contact details…Please post the same..

    Posted by: Nimish | February 3rd, 2005 - 7:32 pm

  81. hi Rahul saxena
    Don’t worry yaar, men of honour are always honoured. dekh lena ek din tum ko sab milke apna indian idol manega. have faith in yourself and every body will have faith in u. anyway u deserve the 1st seat.

    Posted by: Syan | February 4th, 2005 - 12:35 am

  82. Can u plzzzz send me e-mail id of Amit Tandon, Rahul Saxena, Rahul vaidya, Abhijeet, and Prajakta Sukre. they r my heroes.
    A very best of luck 2 u all

    Posted by: Syan | February 4th, 2005 - 12:38 am

  83. dear rahul vaidya
    u r the best SIMPLY the BEST!! u shuld breed the best and bury the rest!! i am ur GREATEST fan yes the GREATEST coz i luv yu ur smile i luv it i don get tired of votin for u till 12 midnight n im not lyin im serious!!

    Posted by: akshita | February 4th, 2005 - 1:18 pm

  84. hey guys i guess its got to be rahul vaidya or prajakta but i guess abhijeet is catchin up real fast
    and INDIAN PUBLIC MUST VOTE ON WAT THEY HEAR AND NOT ON WAT THEIR HEART SAYS

    Posted by: swarup patro | February 4th, 2005 - 5:17 pm

  85. Rahul Vaidya is not having original voice but is tries to copy from Sonu Nigam. That does not mean, he is not talented but I think Amit Sana has got everything in his voice. Abhijeet Sawant also has good sense of music. Sony will definitely produce a private music album for Indian Idol winner and I think for non-flmi and little western style singing Abhijeet’s voice is best suited. He should be choosen as Indian Idol.

    Posted by: Rahul Kharat | February 4th, 2005 - 5:51 pm

  86. Amit sana iam freak abt u!!!!!!!!.Ur voice makes me feellike i am in heaven.I like u so much.I need u r E-mail ID. Best of luck to u.

    Posted by: vinitha | February 4th, 2005 - 7:24 pm

  87. Abhijeet sawant is the best in indian idol. Definately he will be chose as indian idol. Keep up abhijeet… Best of luck from bottom of my heart.

    Posted by: vijay | February 4th, 2005 - 9:27 pm

  88. The present 4 contestants for the Indian Idol are extremely good. Its a difficult decision to choose just 1 among all these talented singers.I wish them all the very best and may the best singer win!
    A few comments:

    Abhijeet- ‘u r an excellent singer and your voice, your looks and your innocence are your plus points. i don’t think the streaked hair suits you. you look good simple…just how you were before! hope u don’t mind this comment! all the best’.

    Rahul - ‘Keep up the 1000 watt smile’:-)

    Prajakta and Amit - ‘You both are not just good singers, but good performers too. good luck’.

    Posted by: J | February 5th, 2005 - 4:28 pm

  89. hey prajakta
    i am a big fan of urs
    but whenever i see u in the bottom three i get very sad
    i think the indians have gone mad as they caanot see the talents of a person like ypu
    i hope this message will make then wake frm their sleep
    i am sure u r goin to be the indian idol
    dont worry i am always there to vote u.
    hey prajakta if u read this message then plz mail me as in my id written below
    love
    iti

    Posted by: iti | February 5th, 2005 - 5:55 pm

  90. we are a family of 4 and we all love amit sana and would like him to become the indian idolhe has a very very original voice of his own and i think that hes great…he does not have to copy anyone…please god make AMIT SANA our INDIAN IDOL

    WE R FROM SINGAPORE….AMIT COME TO SINGAPORE AFTER U BECOME OUR IDOL

    we love your magical voice

    keep it up amit sana and come on to the TOP 1…

    WILL PRAY FOR U AMIT

    LOVES FROM SINGAPORE

    LATA DIKSHA JUHI AND ASHOK

    Posted by: lata ashok khemlani | February 5th, 2005 - 7:07 pm

  91. AMIT AMIT AMIT u r greatest….best of the best…so cute in your own way…

    im 9 years old and i think u r my indian idol

    i see indian idol because of u…..!!!

    keep it up amit sana

    juhi ashok khemlani from singapore

    Posted by: juhi ashok khemlani | February 5th, 2005 - 7:12 pm

  92. WHO IS HE???? OUR WONDERFUL AND FAVOURITE INDIAN IDOL

    I KNOW WHO HE IS….HE IS AMIT SANA OUR INDIAN IDOL…

    IM 13 YEARS OLD AND U R ALREADY MY INDIAN IDOL

    KEEP UP WITH YOUR FANTASTIC WORK

    THIS MESSAGE IS ALL THE WAY FROM SINGAPORE
    FOR U ONLY
    1 AND ONLY

    AMIT SANA!!!!!!

    DIKSHA ASHOK KHEMLANI

    Posted by: diksha ashok khemlani | February 5th, 2005 - 7:17 pm

  93. WHO IS HE???? OUR WONDERFUL AND FAVOURITE INDIAN IDOL

    I KNOW WHO HE IS….HE IS AMIT SANA OUR INDIAN IDOL…

    IM 13 YEARS OLD AND U R ALREADY MY INDIAN IDOL

    KEEP UP WITH YOUR FANTASTIC WORK

    THIS MESSAGE IS ALL THE WAY FROM SINGAPORE
    FOR U ONLY
    1 AND ONLY

    AMIT SANA!!!!!!

    DIKSHA ASHOK KHEMLANI

    Posted by: diksha ashok khemlani | February 5th, 2005 - 7:18 pm

  94. please send us amit sanas email add….would like to get in touch with him our indian idol

    lata ashok

    Posted by: lata ashok khemlani | February 5th, 2005 - 7:20 pm

  95. hai RAHUL VAIDYA!

    how ru? iam fine. Iam a great fan of u! ur voice is

    so good and u will be the INDIAN IDOL surely!

    all the best for u in future!

    bye,

    manju

    Posted by: manjusha | February 6th, 2005 - 1:54 am

  96. hey guys just 4 weeks left and i seriuosly think rahul shd be the indian idol(hope he z readind it)does anyone here know rahul z phone no.or email id pllllllllllllllzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz do give it 2 me

    Posted by: me | February 6th, 2005 - 12:04 pm

  97. ravinder ravi came from a very humble background without any professional knowledge with his inborn talent he reached upto this stage Indians are not emotional fools but they know that with little bit of training & encouragement the poor boy will do wonders those who talk so nasty about him have an upperclass attitude & they cant see a lower class man soaring so high we are great fans of ravinder & we will love to listen to him more & more even if he is not there in Indian IDol

    Posted by: ARATI | February 6th, 2005 - 2:28 pm

  98. hi

    Rahul Vaidya u r simply superb. i like ur voice so much & also ur smile. u r the best of all.i like u so muchh….. ….. but i was very shocked when Rahul saxena out.I think now the jury have to chooseindian idol coz our indians are so emotional .

    hey i like Abhijeet also he is so innocent & his smile is so sweet .his smile always break my heart.
    plzzzzzzzzz Abhijeet work hard coz after Rahul saxena u wanna bacome indian idol plzzz give Abhijeet & Rahul Vaidya’a mail id

    Posted by: krishna | February 6th, 2005 - 2:41 pm

  99. hi SANA
    all the bast for the next round!!!!!!!!!make sure that u r there in the last three!!!!!!!!

    Posted by: vani | February 6th, 2005 - 4:12 pm

  100. hi
    rahul(vaidya) this is mrirani from kolkata u sing superbly and i love ur smile ur choclate boy look its soooooo sweet. i an 17 and am in class 11 in mahadevi birla school probly u will never read my letter but still…… i sometimes feel that if u wud have been like us the boy next door and not the celibrity rahul then it wud have been so nice then we cud have been gud frends any ways i wish u all the best
    with loads of love
    mrirani

    Posted by: mrirani | February 6th, 2005 - 6:04 pm

  101. hi ADITI PAUL

    i am rahi from bangladesh. i am a great fan of your song and your personality.my two sister shaty and nasima also your fan. when eliminated my sister’s was crying, are you belive this? this is true. they told me any how to contruct with you. now i am not interest to INDIAN IDOL because you are not there.
    if possible to contract with me pleaseeeeeeee.
    my e-mail address is raahien06@yahoo.com.

    only your’s
    RAHI

    Posted by: Rahi | February 7th, 2005 - 10:14 am

  102. amit sana
    wish u a very good luck for yr coming rounds &i pray to god that u will be the indian idol.
    beest of luck.

    Posted by: swarnali | February 7th, 2005 - 11:23 am

  103. amit sana
    wish u a very good luck for yr coming rounds &i pray to god that u will be the indian idol.
    beest of luck.

    Posted by: swarnali | February 7th, 2005 - 11:25 am

  104. Dear Abhijeet :-) :-),
    I really like your smile and voice I am ur fan from the first round.i always vote for u. in the piano round u believe or not i gave u 40 votes… and thats true. if u wanna know who i am then i am a 16 years old girl from kolkata.. u will be the indian idol…. Abhijeet best of luck.. and keep smiling.. if u ever read this msg. then plzzzzzzzzzzzzzz…. mail me a little…pls…hope u will see this …
    If any one know ABHIJEET SWANT’S e-mail id or address or phone no. pls. mail me at arpitadas29@yahoo.com…plzzzzz…… :-)..:-)

    Posted by: Arpita | February 7th, 2005 - 1:21 pm

  105. It is disheartening to see Ravinder ravi go Indian idol started with a very good objective there was no disparity or class distinction but off late the attitude of the jury became disgusting specially the way faraha spoke to him towards the end she has no right to be a part of the jury ,after reachng to this position a dignified mannerism is expected from her but she totally lacks that .Ravinder coming to this stage was an encouragement to the lower class also & a message that talent is recognised in India why doesnt our jury understand that the poor fellow is without any training ,it will be a great failure of indian idol if he goes back to the same life may be he doesnt deserve to be an indian idol but he very much deserves to be successful & recognised it is the moral duty of the Indian idol team who has brought him to this stage this to shape his future in this field ,help him to further improve himself & give a good break to help him become a great singer otherwise the whole purpose of the Indian Idol will be defeated

    Posted by: rupal | February 7th, 2005 - 5:49 pm

  106. Hi amit……
    Im nt a big fan of indian idol n i miss wtchn it every week,,,,,bt one thng i dnt miss is lstnin to you sing… no doubt all you finalists are amazin bt as far as my heart goes ur better than the best!! Wthr i wtch the nxt few episodes or not 1 thng is for sure…. il vote for you.
    There is no difference between the left eye and the right eye, they both give us one vision. Likewise with music, the personalities are very different but they give you the totality of one emotional and artistic expression!!!!! ALL THE BEST AMIT,wthr u make it to the final or not, ur a winner in your own right n u deserve the best!

    Posted by: mahi | February 7th, 2005 - 11:23 pm

  107. HEY RAHUL,
    U R IN THE FINAL STAGE NOWWWWW!!!!!!!
    WOWWWWWWWW!! I KNOW WHO IS OUR INDIAN IDOL
    ITS
    NONE
    OTHER
    THAN
    RAHUL
    VAIDYA!!!!
    HEY RAHUL I LOVE U SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH!!U R THE BEST
    ULOOK THE BEST 2222222!!!
    CAN U PLZZZ ZZZZZ EMAIL ME I.D.’S OFR RAHUL VAIDYA AND AMIT SANA ?? I AM GR8 FAN OR THEIRS

    BYE AND BEST OF LUCK!!!!HEY U R SO SWEET
    BYEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

    Posted by: Anisha | February 8th, 2005 - 3:37 pm

  108. congratulations to the last four contestants.
    it is a plesure to watch indian idol.
    i wish all 4 of u very best of luck for the show+for there life ahead.
    no matter if u do not make further but still india loves u all.
    rahul vaidya, i am sure u will be THE INDIAN IDOL.
    i am happy ravinder ravi is out.
    he was the least deserving.
    it is all because of him that adit, rahul……r out.
    bye.

    Posted by: pallavi | February 8th, 2005 - 3:45 pm

  109. hi!!!!!!!
    LATA,DIKSHA,JUHI KHEMLANI
    MAHI
    RAHUL KHARAT
    MAVERICK
    SWARNALI
    VINITHA
    VANI
    BIKRAM
    NEHA SINGH

    I AM HAPPY TO KNOW THAT YOU ARE ALL AMIT SANA FANS
    LIKE ME.I AM GLAD,LIKE MANY OTHERS YOU DON’T GO ON LOOKS.ANYWAYS!AMIT IS TOOOOOO CUTE.

    KINDLY DO DO DO DO VOTE FOR HIM.
    SMS PHONE ALL!!

    BYE

    Posted by: shwetha | February 8th, 2005 - 3:52 pm

  110. hello friends
    myname is sangeeta.iamm 12yrs old.i request utovote for prajakta.she is from my school. sheis in 12th class.i am notsaying to vote her bcos sheis of my school i am saying to vote her bcos she sings well. so pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeeee vote her

    Posted by: SANGEETA | February 8th, 2005 - 5:32 pm

  111. I want to know if the Indian Idol contestants actually read these comments of ours???????????? I hope they do, coz this is what we want to tell them, so I hope the message is being conveyed to them! if not, does anyone know of any other way we can get in touch with them and so that they can also talk to us too!!!!!!!!!

    Posted by: J | February 8th, 2005 - 7:14 pm

  112. Rahul
    u r 2 good

    Posted by: Rabina Bhattarai | February 8th, 2005 - 9:02 pm

  113. Rahul vaidya
    u’r voice is good

    Posted by: Bidit | February 8th, 2005 - 9:06 pm

  114. Rahul Vaidya
    u’r voice is sweet. Plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz sing well. u r our indian idol. All the best.

    Posted by: Rabina | February 8th, 2005 - 9:09 pm

  115. Ravinder should be provided with an opportunity to sharpen his singing calibre & become a playback singer .What was kajol or sharufkhan when they started their carrier or in that matter even sonu nigam practice makes a man perfect& for that he requires opportunity which ofcorse the generous people of our country can provide him with.Farah should be kicked on her ass for having such a rough attitude towards the less deprived if there is justice in this world god will definitely punish her for her rough attitude. madhu

    Posted by: madhu | February 8th, 2005 - 9:35 pm

  116. throw farah out ,give ravinder some chance dont let him go into oblivion it will be hard to see him going back to the same .we

    Posted by: indian voice | February 8th, 2005 - 9:39 pm

  117. Hi its to the final stage now. Only 4 singers left. All are brilliant, but I wish either Amit Sana or Abhijeet Sawant becomes the Indian Idol. Coz I dont like Rahul Vaidya even though he is the best among the 4, coz I feel it is not his real self, he acts on camera that he is a good guy. But i dont think he is, from within he is selfish. I would be happy if Amit Sana becomes the Indian Idol and if not him Abhijeet Sawant. What do u think friends?

    Posted by: Chetan | February 8th, 2005 - 11:45 pm

  118. HI RAHUL CAN YOU PLZ CONVEY my message to rahul vaidya that i am crazy for him and i love him like hell and i think i am the perfect girl for her so plz can u give his mail id than i will be ever grateful to you and i will tell dad to produce a film forr u where you will be the lead singer

    Posted by: LAVANYA | February 9th, 2005 - 12:42 am

  119. hi amit
    all the best to u for the next round .do well!!!!

    Posted by: vani | February 9th, 2005 - 10:40 am

  120. Rahul Vaidya. Nothing 2 say much but i have a deep crush on you and best of luck! no matter what, u’ll always be my indian idol! saw you in Chalti Ka Naam Antakshari!!!!

    Posted by: reggie(raisa) | February 9th, 2005 - 10:45 am

  121. INDIAN IDOL BOLE TO ABHIJEET
    ALL THE BEST TO THE BEST!!

    DEAR VISHAL KOTHARI
    no matter u were the first one to be eliminated, have faith in you and keep the hard work. we never know when the lady luck will open the doors for us so be prepared for the long journey ahead.i wud love to hear u again.ALL THE BEST!

    Posted by: ruchika | February 9th, 2005 - 12:41 pm

  122. I HAVE HEARD THE INDIAN IDOL CD.ALL ARE GOOD.

    BUT . HARISH(Tum bin jaaoon kahan),VISHAL(Dil deewana hai),and AMIT SANA(Pyaar deewana hota hai)
    are FAB!!too COOL!!!!!!

    WITH HARISH AND VISHAL GONE , I THINK AMIT SANA IS OUR INDIAN IDOL.TOO GOOD VOICE,HARD WORKING(by the way he has improved his performance and dance).

    BEST OF LUCK AMIT !!!
    I’LL VOTE FOR YOU.

    Posted by: shwetha | February 9th, 2005 - 3:30 pm

  123. hey guys…
    …gud to hear ‘dat u all are rooting for Rahul Vaidya… actually i’ll let u in for sum secret info :-
    INDIAN IDOL IS NOT BASED ON ALL U PPL’s VOTES… it’s all fixed… Rahul Vaidya will be the emerging winner! …and i can tell u dat wid’ confidence ‘cuz we’ve been freinds since last 4 years… he came into our skool in 8th, Hansraj Morarji, Andheri, Mumbai… rite now we’re both in the same college, Mithibai… studyin’ commerce… 12th! he stays at Lokhandwala in Andheri and if anyone wants to know more abt him or have some work proposals, lemme know and i’ll see if i can help u out… but CRAZY fans ‘n’ GURLS …please IGNORE this… don’t flood my email id wid’ LOVE LETTERS for RAHUL VAIDYA!!! :D
    anywayz… keep on enjoying watchin’ the show…
    CHEERS!!!~!~!

    Posted by: KeaL | February 10th, 2005 - 5:18 am

  124. rahul vaidya is my favourite
    2 4 6 8
    who do we appreciate
    rahul vaidya, rahul vaidya
    east or west
    he is the best
    go go rahul vaidya

    Posted by: rashi | February 10th, 2005 - 1:24 pm

  125. amit sana ur smile is really vvvvvvvvv sweet
    u and rahul vaidya are my favourites
    i did not like ravinderravi but still when he went out ifelt quite bad

    Posted by: rashi dwivedi | February 10th, 2005 - 1:34 pm

  126. its all rigged u fools.. cant u see ?????? that rahul vaidya is gonna win and its all pre decided. god give them some brains.

    Posted by: hotequator | February 10th, 2005 - 1:34 pm

  127. Hi…I am pragya from Nepal. I really like the show Indian Idol. It is really a great show. I hope Amit Sana wins since he is the best of the lot. Aditi was great but I am dazed why she is being voted off. Can anybody pass me email id of amit sana, aditi paul, and amit tandon.

    Posted by: pragya | February 10th, 2005 - 5:35 pm

  128. aditi pal ,

    u r a fantastic singer with tremendous prospect.
    pl.continue in same way as u did.

    Posted by: p.k.ganguly | February 10th, 2005 - 6:31 pm

  129. Hiiiiiiiiiii RAHUL ,
    U R MY FAVOURITE CONTESTENT. I WATCH U IN EVERY GALA ROUND.U R JUST SUPERB. EVEN I LEARN MUSIC & I AM IN 6TH YEAR & U R MY IDOL.EVEN I AM OF YOUR’S AGE. I VOTE FOR U ALWAYS. IF U GET TIME FROM YOUR BUSY SCHEDULE PLZ MAIL ME COZ I AM YOUR BIGEST FAN [A.C] EVERY DAY WHEN I OPEN MY EYES I ASK GOD FOR THE BRIGHTNESS OF YOUR FUTURE . I AM FROM VARANASI[BANARAS].
    I WISH BEST OF LUCK 2 ALL THE CONTESTENTS.
    PLZ REMEMBER ME AS A SMALL BUT CUTE FAN OF YOURS.

    Posted by: Isha | February 10th, 2005 - 11:27 pm

  130. hi amit
    u were good inspite of the bad condition of ur throat. i have voted for u . all the best. and hope to see u in the last three.
    vani

    Posted by: vani | February 11th, 2005 - 8:34 am

  131. KAUN HAI INDIAN IDOL!!!!!!!!!
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    AMIT SANA AUR KAUN……
    YA PHIR ABHIJIT SAWANT
    RAHUL VAIDYA KA OVER ACT KARTA HAI MULAAAAAA.
    RAHUL VAIDYA INDIAN IDOL NA BANE TO SABSE JYADA KHUSHI MUJHE HOGIIIIIIII

    Posted by: jubin | February 11th, 2005 - 11:13 am

  132. RAHUL VAIDYA,
    there is no need to describe u.U’R the best.U’V GOT SUCH A CUTE SMILE.’course i wud b crazy 2 think dat u wud read dis,but still.I LUV U.

    Posted by: Sohini | February 11th, 2005 - 3:28 pm

  133. RAHUL VAIDYA,
    there is no need to describe u.U’R the best.U’V GOT SUCH A CUTE SMILE.’course i wud b crazy 2 think dat u wud read dis,but still.I LUV U.

    Posted by: Sohini | February 11th, 2005 - 3:31 pm

  134. rahul saxena…this one s for u…we all remember u and really miss u…i m waiting for u r next project that is farah s happy new year.
    i m ur biggest fan..wishing u all the best for the future
    garima

    Posted by: garima | February 11th, 2005 - 7:09 pm

  135. I simply love u Rahul Vaidya

    Posted by: Sadhna | February 11th, 2005 - 10:42 pm

  136. hey abhijeet,
    u wound with ur smile and kill with your voice…..abhijeet abhi jeet . u rock….i am head over heels in love with you….
    p.s if u read it and like it plzzzzzzzzzzz mail me

    Posted by: garima | February 11th, 2005 - 10:50 pm

  137. Hi Amit,
    I simply love your voice. you are too good. i desparately hope your throat problem goes away quickly. best of luck. We people in Nepal simply love you.
    Simran

    Posted by: Simran | February 11th, 2005 - 11:03 pm

  138. Amit&Rahul-u both r fantastic.Keep it up.

    Posted by: Ritesh | February 12th, 2005 - 11:31 am

  139. can i have d email id of sana &rahul vaidya?plzzzzzzzz send it 2 me.

    Posted by: imon | February 12th, 2005 - 1:59 pm

  140. i love rahul vaiya, he has such a sexy voice, and smile.He should be indian idol.

    Posted by: kamini | February 12th, 2005 - 2:59 pm

  141. DEAR AMIT SANA, If you are reading this, I have a very honest suggestion for you. Please be very careful while chosing the songs u perform on the show; it really makes difference. With so good voice coupled with good selection, you may be the BEST.

    Try this site for selecting old songs:
    http://www.cs.wisc.edu/~navin/india/songs/

    As far new songs, I hope you can find out urself.

    Select songs which have soul in them.
    OK, wish you all the Best
    girjeshin@yahoo.co.in

    Posted by: girjesh | February 12th, 2005 - 4:50 pm

  142. h rahul
    u r the best and u r my indian idol best of luck

    Posted by: maria | February 12th, 2005 - 6:30 pm

  143. Attention Everyone!
    Rahul Vaidya is the most selfish contestant of Indian Idol.His voice is not original.

    Don`t go for looks.Choose the person who is most deserving.Choose Amit Sana who has oodles of talent. This is not a beauty contest.

    Posted by: garima singh | February 12th, 2005 - 9:08 pm

  144. Rahul Vaidya I love u .ur so sexy and hot.I don’t know why Ilove u .Don’t Worry I’m younger than u

    Posted by: Sadhna | February 12th, 2005 - 9:09 pm

  145. hi rahul vaidya!
    you are absolutely fantastic.i am a gr8 fan of yours…a person with mesmerizing voice and gr8 talent.all the best for future….remember life is beautiful so,just enjoy it’s every moment.you are our indian idol.

    Posted by: neha | February 12th, 2005 - 10:34 pm

  146. hi amit.we just love your voice.i request every1 to vote for him.amit after becoming indian idol,plz come to calcutta.here we people just love u.
    this is for every amit sana fan.lets open a amit sana fan club.anyone really interested plz contact me at
    shreya_juee@yahoo.co.in
    take care sana.it dosnt matter whether u bcome the indian idol or not,u r already our indian idol.get well soon.we all love yoy very much.

    Posted by: shreyami | February 13th, 2005 - 10:28 am

  147. hi amit
    thousand cheers for amit sana.for performing
    so amazingly in spite bad throat.best of luckkk
    for yr coming round from yr 15 yr old fan n i
    do hope that u be ur indian idol.keep up ur good work.

    Posted by: swarnali | February 13th, 2005 - 11:05 am

  148. I happened to see the Antakshari where Rahul Vaidya is seen as a child singer.Today he has grown by leaps and bounds and has featured among the top 3 of the Indian Idol contestants.
    Success seems to have gone to his head.He does not acknowledge his own fellow contestant Abhijeet sawant which was clearly seen in one of the latest episodes of Indian idol.
    Rahul dont count the chickens before the eggs are hatched.Also remember the song from the film Upkaar “Kame wade pyar wafaka” wherein it says Aasman pe udnewale mittime mil jayega!We pray that You do not go the rahul saxena way!

    Posted by: Dr.R.Madhav Rao | February 13th, 2005 - 11:17 am

  149. Look if anyone deserves to win - it’s AMIT SANA.
    Rahul Vaidya is way too arrogant, and when he sings he sometimes isn’t able to control his modulation of throw. Like when he sang during the Republic Day episode, all the alaaps sounded way too over the top.
    Abhijeet Sawant is, well, the worst of the three I think. He’s come up in the past two-three episodes because the themes have been favouring him, his voice is one that can only suit a soft, romantic-ish song. Basically it has no throw, so he really can’t sing a fast paced number nor something powerful.
    But listen, Amit Sana ko bachao - I have a feeling that he’s going next, even though he’s the best, what else can you expect from a nation of people who vote to keep Ravinder Ravi in till the final 5, but boot out a Rahul Saxena so early on in the show.
    AMIT SANA KO BACHAO.

    Posted by: Priyam | February 13th, 2005 - 4:48 pm

  150. Hey everyone, again - I was just on the Indian Idol website (http://www.indianidolonset.com) and was viewing the results of a poll they’re conducting.
    The question is “who will become the first ever Indian Idol?” and the results are as follows:
    Abhijeet Sawant - 63%
    Rahul Vaidya - 21%
    Amit Sana - 16%
    Now, Amit Sana fans, this is a plea to you, next episode vote for Amit Sana like there is no tomorrow, because we have to keep him in - he’s the best there is at the moment.
    It’s a shame that I can’t vote, because I don’t live in India, but I’m hoping that all of you won’t let me down and will vote on my behalf for Amit Sana too.
    Thanks.

    Posted by: Priyam | February 13th, 2005 - 5:35 pm

  151. HI! RAHUL VAIDYA,
    BEST WISHES THAT YOU WILL BE INDIAN IDOL IN FUTURE AND DONT FORGET TO E-MAIL ME. I ALWAYS WATCH U SINGING. U AND PRAJAKTA ARE MY FAVORATES.

    Posted by: Neha Sharma | February 13th, 2005 - 7:50 pm

  152. I LOVE PRAJAKTA .PLEASE BRING HER BACK.
    PPPPPPLEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSEEEE.
    I HAVE E-MAILED U ALL THE WAY FROM NEPAL IN THE BELIEVE THAT U WILL BRING PRAJAKTA BACK.

    Posted by: Neha Sharma | February 13th, 2005 - 7:56 pm

  153. Hi All,

    First of all whenever I see all the guys singing, I feel that Sony Entertainment Television has really done a great job (Keep It UP) to promoting the hidden talents like Prajakta Sukre (You Know She Is My Best), Amit Sana, Rahul Vaidya, & Abhijeet.

    I Would Really Like to Thank Sony for that. We all hope that this type of concept will be brought by Sony in the days to come and we all would get a chance to love artists like PRAJAKTA SUKRE.

    At last, my love to PRAJAKTA SUKRE. She could not be Indian Idol but she will remain my idol forever and ever. But it does not mean that others are better than she. According to me, all are great singers and my judgement goes like this:

    #1: Prajakta Sukre
    #2: Rahul Vaidya
    #3: Amit Sana
    #4: Abhijeet Sawant

    Posted by: Binod | February 14th, 2005 - 8:13 am

  154. Rahul,
    i was SHOCKED 2 c u in the last 2 on friday.IT WAS AWFUL.ANYWAYS DATS DAT.I would like 2 wish u HAPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY VALENTINES DAY.PUHLEASE PRACTISE WELL.It does not matter 2 me wether u sing well or not but pipul dont understand.I REQUEST ALL U PIPUL READING DIS 2 VOTE FOR RAHUL.HE WONT DISAPOINT U.

    Posted by: Sohini | February 14th, 2005 - 3:20 pm

  155. East or west
    PRAJAKTA is the best………..

    Posted by: Neha Sharma | February 14th, 2005 - 6:31 pm

  156. PLEASE VOTE RAHUL VAIDYA
    PPPPPPPPPLLLLLLLLLEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAASSSEEEEEEEE.

    Posted by: